Evidence stolen from police car: Coroner urges
probe into bikie murder
A NSW Coroner has recommended a probe be launched into
the possibility that police caused evidence to be lost in the murder
investigation of a Rebels bikie.
Smajovic, 23, was shot once in the chest soon after arriving at a
Campbelltown car yard with associate David Meatuai at about 2.30pm on
January 9, 2009.
A recent statement by one of the original
investigating officers, Detective Senior Constable Max Kral, has pointed the
finger at Anthony Tan, one of two owners of the Macarthur Auto Centre, who
was initially charged over the murder, along with his colleague Nathan
"From evidence and information available to me at
this time I believe that sufficient evidence exists which identifies that
Tan is responsible for the murder of the deceased Edin Smajovic," Senior
Detective Kral said in the May 2017 document.
A large brief of evidence was tendered
before Deputy State Coroner Teresa O'Sullivan in the Glebe Coroner's Court
during a short hearing on Monday.
After receiving the brief, Ms O'Sullivan delivered
her findings, recommending that the police investigation into the death
"be thoroughly investigated by the Law Enforcement Conduct Commission (LECC),
so as to identify whether the actions of certain officers caused
evidence to be lost".
their case against Mr Tan and Mr Reddy in February 2013 - understood at
the time to be partly due to a confession by a prosecution witness.
In her opening address, counsel assisting the
coroner, barrister Peggy Dwyer, said Mr Reddy had given police
conflicting versions of events during multiple interviews.
Tan has consistently refused to be interviewed.
Senior Detective Kral said he found a version
put forth by Mr Meatuai in August 2009 to be the most believable.
In that recorded interview, Mr Meatuai said Mr
Smajovic had picked him up earlier that afternoon, saying they had to
"go and speak to this guy" before heading to the car yard.
He claimed that while they were speaking to Mr
Reddy outside the workshop doors, Mr Tan walked into the workshop and
retrieved a gun from a white car, cocking it.
Mr Smajovic then allegedly produced his own gun
and held it to Mr Tan's head, telling him repeatedly to put the gun
"Mr Tan shook his head, turned his body to the
left and shot Mr Smajovic, who shot back straight away," Ms Dwyer told
"Mr Smajovic fell face down on the floor and Mr
Tan walked up to him, push kicked him with the bottom of his foot,
called him a 'f---ing dog' and then kicked him in the head. Mr Meatuai
Senior Detective Kral said he
believed Mr Smajovic and Mr Meatuai had attended the workshop over a
drug debt, and that Mr Tan and Mr Reddy had armed themselves following a
He said he believed there was evidence that, after
taking Mr Tan to hospital, Mr Reddy went to an unidentified location and
disposed of the gun used to shoot Smajovic.
Mr Tan was under police guard while being
treated in Liverpool Hospital for a gunshot wound to his shoulder.
According to events in Senior Detective Kral's
statement, the two officers guarding Mr Tan were instructed to
temporarily leave the scene by a superior, giving Mr Tan an opportunity
to wash his hands.
Police later swabbed his hands for gunshot residue
but found no evidence of it.
discharged himself from hospital against medical advice and flew to
Vietnam days later.
Senior Detective Kral said a PACE alert, which
would notify police if Mr Tan attempted to leave the country, had been
requested but not been put in place before Mr Tan left for Vietnam.
Senior Detective Kral said he believed there
was information to suggest Mr Tan signed himself out of hospital "to
prevent covert investigation techniques being used by police against
"I believe he fled Australia days later to
prevent him from being targeted similarly in the ensuing investigation.
I believe this displays evidence of flight and knowledge of guilt," he
Senior Detective Kral said that on January 6,
2010, a NSW Police laptop, a USB thumb drive and a police notebook
issued to investigating officer Detective Senior Sergeant Keith Bristow,
all with information relevant to the murder, were stolen from an
unmarked police car while it was parked in Moore Park.
"This stolen property included records made by
Detective Sergeant Bristow of a conversation he had with an
informant," Senior Detective Kral said.
He said he and Detective Sergeant Bristow
interviewed a man in relation to the murder in July 2010, and that that
man said he'd been told that Mr Reddy had possession of the stolen
laptop, and it had "all the stuff with the case on it".
"The comment about the stolen property was made
without any prompting," Senior Detective Kral said.
Ms Dwyer told the court there were a number of
factors about the police investigation that were of serious concern,
"and may indeed have impacted on your Honourís ability to determine the
manner of death".
"Those matters have now been outlined to the Law
Enforcement Conduct Commission, which has been invited to use its powers
to conduct a full investigation," she said.
Ms Dwyer said she didn't suggest Ms O'Sullivan
suspend the inquest and refer it to the Department of Public
Prosecutions, nor that she make a finding about who shot Smajovic.